Nuttal appears in The Lost Stories: Dinner for Five.


He works alongside two other men, Tomas and Mound. Together they rob Ambrose's house, Ambrose being the local jeweler and Silversmith in Wensley Village by Redmont Castle.

Nuttal distracts Ambrose whilst the other two break in round the back and grab the jeweler, tying him up then raiding the shop before getting away with a number of valubles which Ambrose had been commissioned to repair.

The three then take shelter in Jenny's house, not realizing that she was in it as she was preparing a dinner for two with Gilan. The three take her captive and then help themselves to her food. Making Jenny very mad,Jenny manages to knock Mound unconscious with her rolling pin and then Tomas with a heft leg of lamb before hurling an assortment of knives at Nuttal, who quickly attempts to flee the house and collides with Gilan, who just happened to be walking up to the front door, in the process. Gilan quickly, knocking the small man out cold easily.

It is unknown what happened to Nuttal after that but it is presumed that he was tried and then put in prison.